Friday, May 11, 2018

The Home-Work Question, 1931 – Susan Isaacs offers her thoughts and opinions on home-work for a nine year old


 March 11, 1931 in Home and School "Readers’ Questions"

The Home-Work Question.

Casa” writes: “I would be grateful if you could advise me with my problem of how to deal with lack of sleep on the part of the schoolboy. My little son, aged nine and a half, lies awake every night until generally about 9.45 p.m., and even sometimes as late as 11 p.m. I have done everything to make sleep easy for him, but all my efforts seem useless. He lives a very ordinary schoolboy’s life. He starts at school at a boy’s college at 9 a.m. – having about fifteen minutes’ walk – and finishes at 4 p.m., with an hour and a quarter’s break for dinner, for which he returns home. He has tea at 4.30pm. and   then until 6 p.m. does his homework (of which he has rather a lot, in my opinion), and from 6-7.30p.m. He generally plays with his toys or reads. His supper consists of cereal and milk and three biscuits. He then has a hot bath and is in bed at 8 p.m., with a hot water bottle at his feet. He has a room of his own, and sleeps in the dark with his door open. When questioned as to why he does not go to sleep he says his thoughts keep him awake. He does not play in bed. We keep the house very quiet once the children are in bed. My little girl of five goes to bed at 6 p.m., but also does not sleep until around 8 p.m. I have tried giving the boy a drink of hot Ovaltine, after he goes to bed, and even shutting his bedroom door, but finding him not quite happy with it shut so have gone back to having it open. Both children’s bedrooms get a tiny bit of light from a landing light, but not enough to see to play. I often think the boy looks heavy eyed in the morning, and many a school morning, he would stay in bed. He has just had a very mild attack of chicken pox, during which time I have kept him all day out of doors, but it does not seem to have helped him to go to sleep early. Once he is asleep nothing (thunderstorms or any noise) wakes him. He sleeps absolutely soundly. I think he is of more than average intelligence, with rather a large amount of general knowledge, especially about trains and aeroplanes. He has a wonderful memory, and learns very quickly. The reports form school have been very good up till Christmas, when he seems to have fallen off in his exams, and his report says he is capable of far better work if he would exert himself more. He takes Scott’s Emulsion all the winter, and towards end of term or if he seems pale, Parish’s food. Beyond slight colds he has never been ill and has escaped infectious diseases, although exposed to infection in a marked degree. He is not particularly good at games. He is left-handed, but now writes with his right hand equally well. He has great difficulty in bowling a hoop, skipping, riding a bicycle or hitting a cricket ball, but he is improving as the interest grows. Do you think it would be better if I kept him up later? Up to the present I have felt he was resting although not asleep.”


No, I don’t think it would be advisable to keep your boy up later. You are quite right in saying that the rest and relaxation are good even though he does not sleep. It sounds as if the homework were too heavy for him after a long school day, especially now the evenings are growing lighter and he could be getting exercise and play out of doors after tea. I should be very much inclined to cut down his homework or cut it out altogether, but I don’t feel able to suggest this without knowing more of the school and the boy. So many boys of this age would loathe having an exception made for them in this way, especially if that meant any handicap in school work as a result. To make a special arrangement for him to have no homework might quite possibly increase the troubles in his mind that keep him awake at night. It might perhaps be possible to lessen the amount of it by a talk with the headmaster, as it is quite on the cards that he would do better in school if he had more recreation in the open air and more sleep. Apart from this tentative suggestion I think all you can do is to go on keeping his conditions of life as satisfactory as possible. By the way, you speak of a hot bath. I suppose you are careful to see that this is not too hot? A really hot bath does make some people restless.

No comments:

Post a Comment