July 1938 in Home and School “Readers’ Questions”
Deceitfulness in a seven year old
"D.H.N." writes:-
I should be very grateful if you would advise me regarding the treatment of a little girl aged seven years, who has begun to steal, tell untruths and act deceitfully. This has apparently all happened within the last six months.
The thefts have been little things taken from children’s pockets, e.g., marbles, handkerchiefs, a chain, a purse, halfpennies, sweets, apples. The money was invariably spent on sweets before the child went home. The other things were found hidden in her drawer in the bedroom. The child admitted to the thefts, after careful questioning, at one moment and denied them the next, and even when found with the things in her possession claimed them as her own. At no time did she appear conscious of wrong doing. She has been in the school since she was four years old and her teachers and I always regarded her as one of our brightest and most reliable scholars, calling upon her for leadership and special duties in the school. She is intelligent and possesses a very vivid imagination, e.g. she often plays alone at home, representing a number of characters in her play with perfect imitation. She will live over again activities and special functions which take place in school, using her dolls to express what she wants. She plays quite normally with other children of her own age and is invariably the leader. At school she is interested in her work and happy with her teacher. The child comes from a good working class home. There are three children in the family of which she is the eldest by four years. All the children are nervously inclined and highly strung, and the child in question has from babyhood suffered from nervous habits such a nail biting, finger picking, pulling of clothing and bedclothes to pieces. These characteristics have now almost disappeared. Recently she became very hysterical about the loss of a tooth and gathered a crowd in the park where she was playing. The parents are friendly and sympathetic with the children, giving them equal attention, and allowing reasonable toys and simple possessions. Recently the father’s income has been precarious owing to irregular employment, but the children have never gone short of their requirements. The mother tells me her little girl has only on one occasion taken anything from the home, when she took and hid a cigarette when her father sent her to bring it to him. She has, however, recently begun to rummage in drawers other than her own for no apparent reason. There has just been a development which seems more serious and the act of a more mature mind. The child went into a coffee shop and ordered biscuits in the name of a neighbour saying that the lady would call and pay later. During my thirty years’ experience with little children, I have never come across a case which has puzzled me so much.
The parents are naturally very worried, and having tried simple childish punishments, which have only seemed to arouse defiance, they spoke of resorting to corporal punishment. I have asked them not to do this, but to wait until we could have expert advice before doing anything further. They are willing to sacrifice anything for the child’s good, even sending her to a suitable home for treatment if such were available.
In all the circumstances, you describe, there are two of the child’s experiences which seem to me likely to account for this change in her behaviour. On the one hand, she is losing her teeth, and you describe how strong her feelings were about this, and how hysterical she became.
You may perhaps have read what I wrote recently to explain the anxiety and trouble which second teething often brings to many sensitive children, who secretly feel that they are falling to pieces altogether, and don’t know where the process will end.
It is not at all uncommon for children to begin to steal just at this time. It is as if they felt ‘I must get back what I have lost.’ Of course these feelings have nothing to do with reason but are none the less strong because they are entirely rational.
In this little girl’s case, however, there is a special further circumstance, viz: the family trouble about the father’s irregular unemployment and the uncertainty of income. You say that the children have never gone short of their requirements; but an intelligent child of this age sees and hears everything that goes on around her. She will have heard lots of conversations between father and mother, and will see their anxious faces, and know what trouble they have in their hearts, and since her actual knowledge and experiences are very limited, since she has no way of helping her parents over this trouble, she can only deal with the situation by imagination.
I have no doubt from what you say that the child is in a very great state of anxiety about the family circumstances, and suffers secret fear of starvation, of loss and even of death. And not only is she feeling anxiety but also guilt. Long before this age, children feel even intense guilt about their parents’ troubles, and you describe how this little girl even from babyhood suffered from various nervous habits.
Such nervous nail biting, finger picking etc., always indicates deep-seated guilt as well as anxiety. Children who bite their nails do so partly because nails may scratch and hurt other people. And since this child’s parents are friendly and sympathetic, giving their children all the good things they can, as well as love and attention, it would be very surprising if a highly intelligent imaginative child of this age did not think about things from the parents’ point of view, feel sorry for them, feel grief and remorse for her own naughtinesses towards her parents in the past, and about her need to take so much from them. Most of these feelings will be quite unconscious, but intensely real all the same.
The little drama which you describe, of the child’s going into a shop and ordering biscuits in the name of the neighbour, so strange and so puzzling from the point of view of the adult, can be understood when we know more about the child’s feelings. I would say that she was acting out the fulfilment of a wish. She wanted to believe that her own mother could buy biscuits for her and pay for them later, even if not now. She created this little drama in her mind and acted it out in order to ease the feelings of guilt and distress about the fact that other could not buy the biscuits for her. And this would be not only because she wanted the biscuits, but because she wanted to feel that mother could pay for them, because she wanted to deny the mother’s grief and loss.
It would not help the child or correct the development of her character to punish her physically. In fact no punishment would relive this trouble. If I were you I would talk over the whole situation with the child, and that you understand that she is really very troubled indeed about father’s work. She is really afraid that there will be no food at all, either for her or her father and mother and the other children; and she is so sorry for her mother and father, so troubled that she has even been naughty towards them, that she does not know how to bear these feelings. She steals the toys, money, food, etc., in order to prove to herself in imagination that there are good things in the world for her; and she orders things in the shop in someone else’s name in order to persuade herself that there is still a good mother in the world who will be able to buy her food and all that she needs.
You can be sure, too, that another thing the child is afraid of is that father and mother no longer love her. In their feelings, children often interpret genuine difficulties in the parents’ lives as a sign of a lessened love towards the children themselves. Again, of course, this is completely unreasonable, but that does not make it any less true in the child’s feelings.
It would help her if her father and mother, therefore, could talk over their difficulties very frankly to the child, less often in front of her, but more often directly to her, and in a way that will show the child that there is no loss of love in their hearts, and that their difficulties and anxieties about external things have not made any difference in their feelings towards her.
If, however, there is no improvement in the near future , I would strongly suggest your persuading the parents to take the child to the Manchester Child Guidance Clinic (Atherton Street Schools, Little John Street, Deansgate, Manchester), where they would certainly be able to get help for the troubles which underlie this behaviour.